I’ve been fortunate enough to own and ride almost 70 different bikes over the past decade, ranging from electric and standard bikes to high-end road racers. The unifying theme across all these bikes, be it pedal-powered or electric, is their distinct purpose.
Whether it is repurposing an old Schwinn for scenic rides or tackling rough terrains on the Himiway Cobra, each e-bike has imparted a unique lesson.
Let’s roll into the discussion on how tire size, be it fat or regular, shapes the ride of the electric bike you’re gearing up to consider.
TLDR Regular Tires on an eBike: Best suited for city rides, commuting, and sightseeing on well-maintained paths and paved roads, offering speed, efficiency, and agility in urban environments.
TLDR Fat Tires on an eBike: Ideal for off-road adventures on challenging terrains like loose gravel, sand, and snow, providing enhanced stability, traction, and comfort on bumpy trails.
Pros and Cons of Regular Size Tires on eBikes
My definition of a regular size eBike tire is one that’s less than 3 inches wide. It’s agile and perfect for city rides, offering a smooth glide on paved roads and efficiency for daily commutes.
Now, let’s dive into the pros and cons of using such a tire on an eBike.
|Versatility: Perfect for both urban and country areas, offering a comfortable and fast ride.
|Limited Off-road Capability: Struggles on rough terrains compared to fat tire e-bikes.
|Efficiency: Reduced rolling resistance on paved roads, making them ideal for sightseeing and commuting.
|Traction: Lacks the grip needed for sandy or slippery surfaces.
|Maneuverability: Lightweight and agile, allowing for easy navigation through city streets and parks.
|Fewer flats and lower operating costs
Pros and Cons of Fat Tires on eBikes
Using my definition of a fat tire eBike is one equipped with tires that are 3 inches wide or more, often designed for challenging terrains and off-road adventures. With this in mind, let’s explore the advantages and drawbacks of these robust tires on an eBike
|All-terrain Capability: Excels on loose gravel, sand, and other challenging terrains.
|Weight: Significantly heavier, impacting maneuverability and acceleration.
|Traction: The wide tires provide unmatched stability, especially on tricky terrains.
|Transportation: Their size and weight require a heavy-duty bike rack, making transportation a challenge.
|Comfort: Acts as natural shock absorbers, offering a smoother experience on bumpy trails.
|Technical Trails: The size can make navigating technical trails challenging.
|Increased flats given the wider contact area.
How to Decide What Size Tire eBike to Choose
Your choice should be based on your primary use-case. If you’re looking for sightseeing, city rides, or commuting on well-maintained paths, a regular tire e-bike like my Schwinn would be ideal.
However, if you’re leaning towards off-road adventures on loose terrains, a fat tire e-bike like the Himiway Cobra would be more suitable. Always consider where you’ll ride and the experiences you seek.
Terrain Suitability: On vs Off Road
Regular Tire eBikes: Best suited for on-road terrains like paved roads, city streets, or well-maintained paths. They offer better speed and efficiency on smooth surfaces, making them ideal for urban environments.
Fat Tire eBikes: Perfect for off-road terrains. Whether it’s conquering muddy trails, powering through sandy beaches, or navigating snowy landscapes, fat tire e-bikes can handle it all. However, they might not be the best choice for technical single-track trails.
Performance: Speed, Traction, and Stability
Speed: Regular tire e-bikes, like my Schwinn, are faster on smooth surfaces due to their narrower tires. The word I like to use to describe the regular tire is agile.
Fat tire e-bikes, like the Himiway Cobra, will be slower compared to a narrow tire on these surfaces because of their rolling resistance, width tires and heavier weight.
Traction: Fat tire e-bikes excel in traction, especially on challenging terrains. The wider tires provide enhanced grip. Regular tire e-bikes offer sufficient traction on pavement but may struggle on slippery or uneven surfaces.
Stability: Fat tire e-bikes offer unmatched stability, especially on uneven terrains. Tire pressure on a fat tire bike is an important variable to understand. Running these tire under 10 psi provides amazing stability and traction but it comes with highly degraded maneuverability.
Regular tire e-bikes are stable on paved roads but might not provide the same level of stability on rough surfaces.
Ride eMTB Pro Tip: For serious off-road single-track riding look seriously at a high-end full suspension eMTB with tires in the 2.3-to-2.9-inch width. This will work amazing on the nastiest trails you can throw at it.
Cost and Maintenance Considerations
When it comes to the operational costs, fat tires generally come with a heftier price tag. Their broad footprint, while great for stability, often becomes a target for flats.
For my fat tire eBike, I shelled out $24 USD for a two-pack of 26×4.6 inch tubes, which breaks down to $12 each. In contrast, the tubes for my regular tire bike are approximately $7 USD cheaper.
To combat the frequent flats on fat tires, many riders, including myself, opt for liners. While they’re effective in reducing flats, they’re not light on the pocket. You’re looking at an additional cost of $60 or more per tire.
Tube Costs Comparison
|Type of Bike
|Cost per Tube
|Fat Tire eBike
|26×4.0 inch and up
|Regular Tire Bike
|26×1.8 to 2.5 (Standard Size)
For my commuter bike, equipped with a 2.1-inch wide tire, the replacement costs stand at $30 each. With over 600 miles clocked on this set, I estimate another 300 miles before they need replacing.
On the other hand, the Himiway’s CST Roly Poly 26×4.8 tires come with a steeper price tag of $70 each. Notably, they began showing wear signs just after 110 miles. I anticipate a replacement will be due between the 300-to-400-mile mark. More on CST Roly Poly tires here.
Tire Costs Comparison
|Type of Bike
|Cost per Tire
|Estimated Mileage Before Replacement
|Regular Tire Bike
|Fat Tire eBike
Understanding Suspension Systems: Enhancing Your eBike Ride Comfort
When it comes to eBike rides, comfort is paramount for me. Beyond just the tire size, the suspension system plays a significant role in shaping my riding experience. Here are some things to consider along with the tire size:
No Suspension (Rigid Frame):
On bikes without any suspension, often referred to as rigid frames, I truly feel every nuance of the terrain. They’re lightweight and straightforward, but on bumpy trails, I do miss that extra cushioning.
Ride eMTB Tip: I don’t recommend getting a rigid frame ebike, if you’re spending the premium funds to go electric, add a little more to get some suspension.
Front Fork Suspension (Hardtail):
My Schwinn conversion is a hardtail with a suspension seat post, which boasts a front fork suspension, the front-end bumps are noticeably softened. It’s a delightful balance, especially when I’m transitioning between smooth roads and uneven terrains.
The Himiway is a full suspension bike, equipped with both front and rear suspension, is my go-to for the roughest trails. The ride feels cushioned, and I can spend hours off-road without feeling the usual fatigue or stress on my body.
Suspension Seat Post:
I decided to add a suspension seat post to my Schwinn and my wife’s Aventon. It’s been a game-changer. It offers that extra layer of cushioning right under me, making any bike more comfortable and a tad more forgiving on rough patches.Top of Form
I’ve got a group of articles explaining why eBikes are Awesome Check Them Out Below 👇
- I love riding eBikes, want to learn why? Read 👉 What Are The (Great) Features of Electric Bikes?
- Are you weighing the Pros and Cons of getting an eBike? Let me help 👉 Electric Bike Pros and Cons
- Interested in how it “feels” to ride an eBike? Awesome 👉 What Does it Feel Like to Ride an eBike?
- What is “Pedal Assist? Let me explain it in this article. 👉 What is Pedal Assist and How Does it Work?
Kicking Up Dust on Your Ebike
Choosing between a regular tire e-bike and a fat tire one boils down to your specific needs and preferences. For me, each bike serves a unique purpose, from sightseeing in national parks to off-road cruising.
If you’re considering diving into the world of e-bikes, think about where you’ll ride and what experiences you seek. Both types have their strengths and weaknesses, but the adventures they offer are limitless.